For anyone buying with a partner, sibling, friend or business associate in Victoria, the choice between joint tenants and tenants in common decides who gets the whole property when one owner dies, whether unequal deposits count for anything, and how hard it is to exit later. Most buyers sign the contract without making that choice properly. The transfer form then records a default, and the consequences surface years later, often at the worst possible moment. This guide explains how each structure works and what it means for your conveyancing.
Table of Contents
- Quick Takeaways
- What Joint Tenancy Means in Victoria
- Tenants in Common in Practice
- Survivorship and What Happens at Death
- How Ownership Shows Up on the Title
- Changing Ownership After Purchase
- Conveyancing Steps That Lock In Your Structure
- Side by Side Comparison
- Who Should Choose Which Structure
- Frequently Asked Questions
- References
Quick Takeaways
| Key Insight | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Joint tenants always hold equal shares | Each owner holds an equal interest on title, even if one person paid most of the deposit. Any different understanding has to be written down separately. |
| Survivorship overrides your will | If you hold as joint tenants, your share passes to the surviving owners at death. Your will cannot redirect it. |
| Tenants in common can hold unequal shares | Fractions such as 70 and 30 percent are recorded on title, and each share passes under the owner’s estate. |
| Silence on the transfer defaults to joint proprietorship | Land Victoria guidance says the manner of holding defaults to joint proprietorship if you do not specify your preference in the transfer of land document. |
| Selling one share usually changes the structure | A sale or transfer of one owner’s interest generally ends a joint tenancy and leaves the remaining owners as tenants in common. |
| Check the title search before settlement | The names and manner of holding on the title must match the contract and transfer. Catch mismatches before settlement, not after. |
What Joint Tenancy Means in Victoria
The Land Victoria glossary defines joint tenancy as ownership of land in common by two or more persons where there is a right of survivorship. That single feature drives most of the decisions couples and close friends make at settlement. It is the default most people end up with, whether they meant to choose it or not.

Equal shares regardless of who paid
Joint tenants hold equal shares on title. If three people buy a Carlton terrace and one of them contributes 60 percent of the deposit, the title still records three equal one-third interests. The contribution does not change the registered shares.
In practice, this is the point that surprises most buyers. The title tells the Land Registry who owns the property, but it says nothing about who paid what. That gap is where disputes start.
Why a joint tenancy has to start equal
The classic requirements are that the owners acquire their interests at the same time, through the same document, and in equal shares. If you buy together and later want to hold unequal shares, a joint tenancy cannot simply be relabelled. The structure has to change through a separate transfer and the paperwork that comes with it.
Tenants in Common in Practice
Tenants in common is the more flexible structure. Each owner holds a defined share, and those shares can be unequal, recorded on title as fractions. Investors, business partners and people who are contributing different amounts often choose this route.
Unequal shares recorded on title
Take two siblings buying a Geelong family home where one is lending significantly more money. They might hold 70 and 30 percent, with the fractions shown on title. That result matches what they agreed, which is the point of choosing tenants in common.
The catch is that the fractions show the outcome, not the reasoning. Nothing on the title explains why the split is 70 and 30, and that reasoning is exactly what a co-ownership agreement should record.
Exit rights and the unwanted new co-owner
A tenant in common can generally sell their share without the other owners signing. That freedom is useful, but it can also leave you with a stranger on title. Whoever buys the exiting share steps into the co-ownership position.
Pro tip: Before choosing tenants in common, write down the shares you intend and the reason for them. A right of first refusal in your co-ownership agreement gives the remaining owners the first chance to buy an exiting share.
Survivorship and What Happens at Death
Survivorship is the defining difference. Under a joint tenancy, when one owner dies, their interest passes to the surviving owners as a matter of law, and generally without the estate going through the process of probate. Under tenants in common, a deceased owner’s share forms part of their estate and passes under their will or under intestacy rules.
Why a will may not control a joint tenancy
If your will leaves your share of a jointly held home to your children, that gift does nothing if you hold as joint tenants. Your interest ends at death, so there is nothing left to pass. Many people only discover this when the family reads the will.
The reverse is also true. If you hold as tenants in common, your will does control your share, so a neglected will can send an interest to the wrong person or into a lengthy estate process.
Transmission paperwork after a death
The survivor still has to update the title. In practice, that means providing a death certificate and lodging the paperwork that removes the deceased owner’s name from the register. Your conveyancer can prepare it, but it is a separate job with its own forms and timing.
The title decides how ownership moves at death, long before anyone writes a will.
How Ownership Shows Up on the Title
The manner of holding is recorded on the title and carried into the transfer of land document at settlement. When nobody makes an active choice, the default is joint proprietorship, which means joint tenancy for most practical purposes. This is the most common mistake we see, and it usually happens because the buyers were focused on the price and the finance.

Reading the manner of holding on a title search
A conveyancer checks the title search for the registered owners and how they hold the property. The names and manner of holding should match your contract and your instructions. If they do not, the mismatch needs to be fixed before the transfer is prepared.
Do not assume that the contract will settle the question. The contract describes the property and the sale, while the title shows the owners. A buyer who reads only the contract may not notice that the structure they wanted was never recorded.
What default ownership means for buyers who did not decide
Buyers who sign in a hurry and leave the ownership question blank end up as joint proprietors. If they later want unequal shares, they need a transfer, with duty and tax questions to consider. Deciding at the start is far cheaper than changing the structure years later.
Pro tip: Put the ownership structure in your written instructions to your conveyancer, including every owner’s full legal name and the shares you want. Then check the title search yourself before settlement.
Changing Ownership After Purchase
You can change how you hold a property after purchase, but it is rarely simple. Moving from joint tenancy to tenants in common, or adding and removing owners, requires documents and can carry duty and tax consequences. Get advice before lodging anything.
Severing a joint tenancy
A joint tenancy is generally broken when one owner sells or transfers their interest. The remaining owners then hold as tenants in common, usually in the shares they already had. That outcome often surprises owners who thought the structure would stay put.
Some owners try to sever a joint tenancy by a written notice rather than a sale. The correct method depends on the facts, so confirm it with a conveyancer or lawyer before acting.
Adding or removing an owner
Adding a new owner, such as a partner or child, requires a transfer that records the new shares. Removing an owner after separation or a family breakdown follows the same path, and it needs the agreement of everyone involved.
When co-owners cannot agree
If co-owners cannot agree on a sale, division or buyout, the dispute can go to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal, which can order a sale. That outcome is costly and slow. A co-ownership agreement with a clear buyout formula is the cheaper route.
Conveyancing Steps That Lock In Your Structure
The ownership structure is settled in conveyancing, not after it. Each stage of a Victorian purchase has a point where the names and manner of holding can be checked, corrected or ignored. Using that process properly is what keeps your structure intact.

Instructions before the contract is signed
Write down the owners, the shares and the manner of holding before the contract is signed. A Toorak or St Kilda buyer with a more complex structure, such as a family trust or a business partner, needs those details confirmed early. Late changes to the names on a contract are slow and can jeopardise the timetable.
The Section 32 and title check
The Section 32 vendor statement includes the title documents for the property. A review at this stage is where mismatches between the contract, the title and your intended structure are caught. We offer a free Section 32 review, which is a useful checkpoint before you commit.
Transfer documents and settlement
The transfer of land document records how the buyers will hold the property. Unequal shares must be typed exactly as agreed, with no rounding or shorthand. A small error at this stage can follow the property through every future sale.
Pro tip: Ask your conveyancer to read back the owners and the manner of holding from the draft transfer before you sign. Two minutes of checking here saves a correction process after settlement.
Side by Side Comparison
The table below sets out the practical differences between the two structures. Use it as a starting point for the conversation you need to have with your co-owners before settlement.
| Feature | Joint Tenancy | Tenants in Common |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership shares | Equal shares for every owner | Unequal shares can be recorded |
| Death of one owner | Share passes to surviving owners automatically | Share passes to the deceased owner’s estate |
| Effect of a will | Does not control the joint share | Controls the share held by the deceased |
| Unequal contributions | Title shows equal shares, so a separate agreement is needed | Shares can match the contributions on title |
| One owner sells their interest | Usually ends the joint tenancy | Buyer steps into the co-owner position |
Reading the table for your situation
If you are buying with a partner and expect to stay together, joint tenancy keeps things simple at death. If you are buying with people whose contributions differ, tenants in common is usually the more accurate record. The right answer depends on who is contributing and what each of you expects to happen next.
Where the table can mislead
Overseas commentary on these structures often uses US framing, and the table above reflects the general concepts. Victorian titles, transfer forms and duty rules govern your purchase. Confirm the detail with a Victorian conveyancer before you rely on any comparison.
Who Should Choose Which Structure
There is no single right answer, but there are patterns. The structure that fits a couple buying their first home is rarely the one that fits two investors or a business partnership. The table is only useful once you know which group you belong to.
Couples and families
Couples buying a home together often choose joint tenancy so the survivor keeps the property without a probate process. That works well when contributions are roughly equal and both partners are comfortable with that outcome. If the contributions differ sharply, a written agreement should accompany the choice.
Investors and business partners
Investors and business partners usually need tenants in common, with shares that reflect each person’s money and risk. The ability to transfer a share without the other owners signing is useful here, but a right of first refusal and a buyout formula are essential safeguards. Without them, a single exit can change the entire arrangement.
Self-managed super funds and foreign buyers
Where a self-managed super fund is one of the owners, superannuation rules set the structure, and the arrangement must be checked before the contract is signed. Foreign buyers also need to consider foreign investment approval requirements before deciding how the property will be held. Our team handles both situations, and the structure should be settled at the start, not at settlement.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can joint tenants hold unequal shares in Victoria?
No. A joint tenancy requires equal interests for every owner. If you need unequal shares, you should hold as tenants in common and have the fractions recorded on the title.
Does a will override a joint tenancy?
No. Survivorship applies to a joint tenancy, so the deceased owner’s share passes to the surviving owners before the will is considered. A will only controls the share of an owner who holds as a tenant in common.
Can I change from joint tenants to tenants in common after buying?
Yes, but the change needs the correct documents and may carry duty and tax consequences. A conveyancer or lawyer should confirm the method and the costs before anything is lodged.
Do we need a co-ownership agreement if we are married?
The law does not require one, but a written agreement is valuable because the title does not record who contributed what. It is most useful when contributions, responsibilities or future plans differ between the owners.
Does my conveyancer check how we are recorded on title?
Yes. The title search should show the registered owners and how they hold the property. Your conveyancer should compare that against the contract and your written instructions before settlement.
Does the choice matter if we are buying an investment property?
It matters even more. Investors often have different contributions, different exit plans and sometimes different tax positions. Tenants in common, supported by a written agreement, usually gives the clearest record of what each owner expects.
Did you choose joint tenancy or tenants in common when you bought, and would you make the same decision again? We would like to hear about your experience.